Varieties of the Old Fashioned cocktail are abound, each offering a unique twist on the classic recipe.
From personal creations to regional adaptations, the Old Fashioned has inspired countless variations that showcase the creativity and diversity of mixology.
Here are some notable variations of the classic Old Fashioned that stay true to the essence of the original drink.
1. Classic Old Fashioned
The classic Old Fashioned stands as perhaps the most renowned whiskey cocktail globally. Essentially comprising bourbon, a hint of sugar for sweetness, and a dash of bitters, its simplicity belies the complexity of flavors it embodies.
While its preparation may be straightforward, within this fundamental framework lies a realm of subjective interpretations and nuanced tastes.
2. Benton’s Old Fashioned
Crafted by the inventive mixologist Don Lee at the renowned New York City bar PDT, the Benton’s Old Fashioned sparked the trend of fat-washed spirits.
Infusing bourbon with country ham adds a savory depth, complemented by maple syrup and bitters.
3. Brown Butter Old Fashioned
An homage to the flavors of the South, this New Orleans version elevates the Old Fashioned with brown sugar and bourbon washed with brown butter, enhancing its nutty notes and richness.
Brown Butter Old Fashioned Recipe
4. Brandy Old Fashioned (a.k.a. Wisconsin Old Fashioned)
Hailing as the unofficial state drink of Wisconsin, this variation emerged during Prohibition when muddled fruit masked the taste of inferior spirits.
Despite its origins, the Brandy Old Fashioned remains a beloved rendition of the classic, revered for its unique character.
5. C&B Old Fashioned
Named for its inclusion of Campari and Benedictine, this gin-based twist may share similarities with the Negroni, yet it stays faithful to the Old Fashioned’s blueprint by balancing bitter, sweet, and spirituous elements.
6. Irish Old Fashioned
Conceived by Jack McGarry, co-founder of The Dead Rabbit, this rendition substitutes granulated sugar with Benedictine, imparting an Irish whiskey-based Old Fashioned with distinctive complexity and depth.
7. Oaxaca Old Fashioned
Originating from the innovative mind of Phil Ward at Death & Co. in New York, this creation played a pivotal role in popularizing mezcal in the U.S.
With its smoky allure and agave-forward profile, the Oaxaca Old Fashioned has become a staple in the realm of agave spirits.
8. Rum Old Fashioned
Infused with the flavors of dark rum, allspice dram, and demerara syrup, this variation mirrors the essence of its whiskey-based predecessor while introducing layers of complexity and richness.
Find Your Perfect Variation Of The Old Fasioned
Each of these Old Fashioned variations pays homage to the original cocktail while showcasing the ingenuity and diversity of contemporary mixology.
Whether you prefer the smoky allure of mezcal or the rich warmth of aged rum, there’s an Old Fashioned variation to suit every palate and occasion.
Check out some more variations of the Old Fashioned cockktail at Drinkies.
